A cheaper tub can mean a bigger ice bill. Compare bagged ice with chiller setup, electricity and upkeep using your own numbers.
What the example adds up to.
Four plunges a week, two $5 bags per plunge: $2,080 a year in ice. A chiller using 3 kWh/day at $0.16/kWh, plus $8 monthly upkeep, costs $271.20 a year to run.
Add setup cost before comparing.
With an illustrative $1,200 setup, the chiller’s first-year total is $1,471.20: $608.80 less than ice at these inputs. Simple payback is about 8.0 months. These are examples, not a product price or performance claim.
Change frequency, keep the other example inputs fixed.
Plunges / week
Yearly ice
Chiller setup + year one
Lower total
1
$520.00
$1,471.20
Ice by $951.20
4
$2,080.00
$1,471.20
Chiller by $608.80
7
$3,640.00
$1,471.20
Chiller by $2,168.80
Two $5 bags/plunge; $1,200 setup; 3 kWh/day; $0.16/kWh; $8/month upkeep. Holding chiller energy fixed is an illustration, not a claim that every routine uses the same energy.
If chiller operation costs as much as or more than ice, there is no operating-cost payback. An eventual payback does not mean the chiller is cheaper within your chosen period.
Assumes year-round use and constant inputs. Excludes common tub and water costs, financing, resale, repairs beyond entered upkeep, and the value of your time. If the routes need differently priced tubs or other extra equipment, include that difference in the setup amount.
Where do my ice and energy numbers come from?
Use the ice bath calculator for a fresh cooling cycle. An already-cold tub may need less on its next use. Daily chiller energy is best based on measured kWh over a representative day: rated watts alone do not capture cycling, pumps, climate or insulation.
Compare the gear behind the numbers.
A cost result is a planning aid, not a product recommendation. Check fit, capacity and package contents.
Considering a simple ice tub?
The Cold Pod 85-gallon tub with full-wrap thermal cover is one option to compare. No chiller included.
Paid link. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Bundle details to check
Listed outer size: 29.5 × 29.5 × 29.5 in. Leave room for ice and your body. Listing checked September 30, 2026; not hands-on tested. Confirm price, seller, usable space and package contents.
Considering a chiller?
Match cooling capacity to your volume and climate. Check pumps, filters, connections and installation costs.